Sleepless nights (Jeff the killer)

This was the original work to my Jeff the killer x reader Sleepless nights story. All x reader versions can be found on my tumblr https://www.tumblr.com/blog/sunako-okami

This was the third night in a row Sunako couldn’t sleep. Her paranoia was getting the best of her. She wishes she could get back to sleep, but she just can’t. Every time she lays down and closes her eyes, she hears something outside her door or taping her window. She couldn’t tell if it was real or not anymore. Her border between fiction and reality was broken.

She looked at the clock next to her; the time was 3:28 AM. When she was younger, she would go to her big brother, who would let her sleep in his room for the night. She was too old for that now. No 15 year old should be sleeping with their older brother. She looked out the window for a minute, staring at the full moon shining in the window, as clouds occasionally passed by. She stared at the light cast on her floor. Different shadows were cast on the ground, making odd shapes.

One shape stood out to her the most, it was shaped like a person, and it was moving. Sunako gasped and looked at her window. She could have sworn she saw a shadow moving across it and out of her sight. Sunako just shook her head and got up to go to the kitchen.

“I just need a drink, that’s all,” she told herself and went into the hallway. As she made her way down the hall her eyes glanced around the space. Looking at anything that she thought had moved. When she made her way into the kitchen, she sighed in relief, leaning against the wall.

“Every night, when the moon is in the sky, I open my eyes to see their smiles. They play in the shadows and roam in the trees, playing their foolish trickery,” she sang. It was an old song she wrote with her brother when she was younger. It helped her sleep at night when her brother was out.

She sat up and grabbed a glass out of the cabinet, she filled it with water and put it to her lips, ready to sip it. When another noise filled her ears. She jumped and turned around to see the window next to the hallway opening was ajar. She sighed and moved to close it. “Must have been the wind,” she told herself. Though, she could have sworn that it was closed when she went to bed. Maybe Hibiki opened it.

She grabbed her glass and went into her room setting the glass on her nightstand, before moving to grab a book off of her bookshelf. She chose a fantasy novel, it was her favorite. A book about a girl who challenged her fears to save the one she loved the most. The characters were easy to connect to and made her feel a little more courageous, After making it halfway through the book, she looked at her cloak again. It was 5:42 AM. Only two more hours until she had to wake up. She sighed and closed her book, and sipped from her half-empty glass. She then laid to so she could rest before waking up the next morning.

Just as she was falling asleep, she heard her door open. She sat up straight looking at her door which was now wide open. She never slept with her door open, she always closed it. Hibiki couldn’t have come into her room in the middle of the night, he hates waking up early. She got up and closed her door. Then reached under her pillow for the blade she kept underneath it. It was gone.

“Looking for this?” a raspy voice had said behind her. She froze. She must be hearing things. She couldn’t have really heard them. She just misplaced the blade. Though, while she thought this, deep down inside, she knew this wasn’t true.

She turned around to see a male towering over her. His hair was black and reached his shoulders. His skin was unnaturally pale. White even. His eyes were wide, she then realized that they were just lacking eyelids. His mouth had a smile cut into it. It had healed, but the scars were obvious. She knew who he was, though she wished that she would never have to see his face again

“I told you to stop stalking me,” she said, trying to mock confidence, but she knew that Jeff could see right through her.

“Since when have I ever listened to you,” Jeff said, smiling, making the scars on his face blend in with his mouth even more. He had leaned down to her height and grabbed her chin. She jerked her head back at the touch, and turned her face away, trying to hide the blush that touched her cheeks.

He chuckled. As much as Sunako hated to admit it, she loved that chuckle. She used to be absolutely enchanted by Jeff. She had devoted her heart to him and him only. When she had heard of what Jeff had done to his family, she was in disbelief. It didn’t sound like the Jeff she loved. Though, she knew of the bullying that had happened beforehand, and as much as she hated it. She felt that what he did to the bullies was completely justified.

He had come to her once before after the murders he committed. She had told him to leave her alone and threatened to call the authorities. Though, they both knew she had no intention of doing so. They knew this because she still loved him. As much as she hated to admit it her heart still belonged to him.

“You shouldn’t be here, Jeff. Someone will hear you,” she said, trying to reason with him. Though something else inside her told her to let him stay. She tried to ignore the urge, but it was yelling over all her logic.

“I’ve done a lot of things I shouldn’t do and look. They’ve made me beautiful!” Jeff exclaimed. Referring to his face. Sunako gave up and sat down. Tears threatened to spill over her eyes. Jeff stopped smiling and kneeled next to her bed.

“Hey, you know I still love you, right?” he asked me. I looked up at him confused. Though, the look in his eyes told me all I needed to know. I nodded and wiped my face of tears. “I know…” I said in a low whisper. Staring at my hands.

“Do you still love me?” he asked. She nodded her head quickly, knowing that there was now no point in denying it. He couldn’t possibly gain anything from it. She was now unarmed. Screaming would only put herself and others in danger. Against her better judgment, she leaned on Jeff and rested her head on his shoulder. He wrapped his arm around her and tried to soothe her with small up and down motions.

Sunako turned fully to hug Jeffery one last time. She felt his arms wrap around her as tears fell down her cheeks. She could tell by his breathing that she wasn’t the only one crying. “I love you,” was going to be the last thing she thought she'd ever got to say to him. “I love you too.”

***

“15-year-old girl, Sunako Okami found dead in her bedroom. Was this another victim of the newfound serial killer Jeff the killer? The evidence says yes, but this is unlike his other killings. She was said to be found in her room by her brother. Police say the only wound was a single stab wound to her back. There were no forms of struggle or disturbance to the body-

I cut off the TV, “There you happy now? I did it. I killed her,” I told Slender. Killing Sunako was by far the hardest thing I’ve had to do since my new-found career. Slender’s reasoning. She was a distraction, a weakness. I didn’t need her. He was wrong. I did need her. Now I’ll never see her again.

At least I’ll rest assured knowing that the last thing I got to say to her was that I love her. ‘I really do love you, Sunako... and I always will’

“I love you too, Jeff”

#jeffthekiller #originalcharacters #creepypasta #oneshots #fanfictions